Meet the Team

Dr. James Fonner opened the doors to First Choice Chiropractic in 2007 with his first office in North Columbus. His belief in natural pain relief motivated him to open a chiropractic office that provides rehabilitative care without the use of any surgery or prescriptions. But where did this passion begin?

James Fonner grew up in the Northeastern city of Wooster, Ohio before he made the decision to follow his dream of becoming a chiropractic doctor at Logan University in Missouri.

After his 4 years of chiropractic education in Chesterfield, Missouri, he received his doctorate of chiropractic and moved back to his home state of Ohio.

Once back in Ohio, Fonner made the move to central Ohio and decided to open his first chiropractic office in North Columbus.

He worked hard to grow his chiropractic office to a well-known and respected recovery center for accident and work injuries. He understood that the accident recovery process can be stressful.

Physicians and Back Pain Specialists in Columbus Ohio

With the success of his first office, he went on to establish two more personal injury chiropractic offices on different sides of the city. Fonner now helps clients to relieve their accident injuries not only on the north side of Columbus, but the East and South side as well.

Not only does his team provide the proper care and specific treatment plans for their clients to recover as quickly as possible, but they will guide their patients through the entire recovery process after a car accident or work injury. From working with experienced accident attorneys and reliable body shops over the years, Fonner’s First Choice Chiropractic team has the team for their clients to get well, and get compensated.

Born and raised in Columbus Ohio. Dr Pleasant completed his undergraduate degree at The Ohio State University. He obtained his doctorate degree at Palmer Chiropractic College (Florida). In his early days he would always tell everyone that he wanted to be a doctor and decided on an alternative approach beyond traditional medicine. Over the years he became intrigued by the body and its natural ability to heal itself. Chiropractic medicine became a perfect fit, he could still become a physician in a field that encourages his strengths and philosophy on life. Dr. Pleasant strongly believes his purpose in life is to assist others.

Dr Pleasant feels it is necessary to have a caring attitude, patience and strong interpersonal skills. Hard work and determination are two aspects that have carried him throughout life. He has always been able to relate well with people from very diverse socioeconomic backgrounds. As a physician he feels it is important to communicate compassionately and effectively with patients daily. Dr. Pleasant has practiced for over 18 years and has extensive background in the personal injury field.

Dr. Valarie Dills has been helping patients live healthier, more balanced lives since earning her Doctorate of Chiropractic from Palmer College of Chiropractic in Port Orange, Florida in 2016. With nearly a decade of hands-on experience, she brings compassion, skill, and a patient-first approach to her role as Clinical Director at First Choice Chiropractic in Newark, Ohio.

A proud Ohio native, Dr. Dills earned her Bachelor of Science in Kinesiology with a pre-med concentration from the University of Toledo before pursuing her chiropractic studies. Her early work with children and individuals with special needs helped shape her belief that every person deserves care tailored to their unique needs—no matter their age or background.

At First Choice Chiropractic, Dr. Dills provides a full range of general chiropractic care while also focusing on personal injury and workers’ compensation cases. She is passionate about helping patients recover from accidents and injuries, guiding them through personalized treatment plans designed to relieve pain, restore mobility, and support long-term wellness.

Dr. Dills is also specialized in pregnancy, infant, and pediatric chiropractic care. She holds certification in the Webster Technique, which supports prenatal comfort and healthy fetal positioning. She is a member of the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association and enjoys seeing patients all ages from newborns into the golden years.  In addition, she incorporates a variety of modern therapeutic approaches—such as dry needling, gua sha, cupping, soft-tissue therapy, and activator methods—to help her patients move and feel their best.

Outside the clinic, Dr. Dills enjoys spending time outdoors with her husband and son, exploring Ohio’s trails through hiking, bicycling, backpacking, and canoeing. She’s also a creative at heart—an avid LEGO builder, holistic cook, animal lover, and proud “pet mom” to two large dogs and two mischievous cats.

Above all, Dr. Dills believes in listening first—because every patient has a story, and every story matters. She is honored to provide the Newark community with thoughtful, individualized chiropractic care that helps patients of all ages recover, heal, and thrive.

Dr. Brittani Young is dedicated to providing natural, sustainable pain relief and preventative care for her patients. She received their Doctor of Chiropractic degree from Palmer College of Chiropractic Florida. Prior to that, Dr. Young obtained her undergraduate degree from the University of Cincinnati where she was a part of the women's basketball team. With over 16 years of experience, Dr. Young has garnered the respect of patients and the local community by providing exceptional care for ailments such as lower back pain, sports injuries, headaches, and more. She is passionate about using her skills and knowledge to help others live a healthier and more productive life. When she's not in the office, you can find her officiating youth and high school basketball or competing in electronic dart leagues/tournaments.

Dr. Trevan Price is a dedicated chiropractor with more than 11 years of clinical experience, specializing in personal injury care and rehabilitative treatments. A proud graduate of Logan University, Dr. Price has built his reputation on a foundation of integrity, precision, and compassion. He takes a patient-centered approach to care, tailoring every treatment plan to meet the unique needs of each individual, whether they are recovering from an accident, managing chronic pain, or striving to return to their favorite activities stronger than before.

Known for his calm demeanor and hands-on expertise, Dr. Price is passionate about helping his patients not only recover physically but also regain confidence in their bodies and daily lives. He believes that true healing comes from understanding the whole person, not just their symptoms, and takes pride in creating a welcoming, supportive environment for everyone who walks through his doors.

Originally from Lewisburg, Kentucky, Dr. Price has carried his small-town values of honesty, hard work, and community into every aspect of his practice. Outside of the office, he enjoys spending time outdoors, whether hiking, camping, or simply enjoying the fresh air. He is also an avid reader and music lover, often exploring new genres and artists in his free time.

At home, Dr. Price shares his life with his partner and their two beloved dogs, Deacon Blues and Ziggy Smalls, who are constant sources of joy and laughter. While his days are filled with helping patients move past pain, his favorite moments are the ones when he sees them smile and realize they can once again do the things they love, pain free.